I'm a huge Sally Hansen CSM fan. They are some of my favorite drug store polishes. And I've never had a bad polish.
Shiny Penny was the one and only polish I picked up from the fall limited edition. The color name is pretty much spot on. It does look like a shiny new penny and dries to a shimmery - almost foil-y finish.
The formula was very difficult to work with. My bottle was thin. I had issues with cuticle flooding. I had issues with terrible streaking and brush strokes. And I had trouble with bubbling the first time I swatched it because the dry time seems to be longer than average. I had such high hopes for this one, but am left pretty disappointed with the quality.
I love SH polishes and hope that I just got a bad bottle. The color is pretty anyway. Right?